Active (Ethernet) vs. Passive (PON) — What's Best for You?

13 Feb 2019

When it comes to delivering networks to support Smart Buildings and applications like CCTV, IPTV and Internet service delivery, there is no doubt the near-limitless bandwidth of optical fiber is of benefit. What is less clear is whether an active or passive technology is better. The reality is that it depends on many factors including the environment, applications being used and who is going to manage or operate the infrastructure. Let’s look at this in a little more detail.

History and Background 
Active Ethernet or point to point Ethernet has been used extensively in a broad range of applications and environments for many years from the early days of 10BaseT to the current Ethernet technologies that utilize copper or optical fiber to deliver 1G, 10G and beyond.

In order to deliver next-generation services to consumers or subscribers, the aging twisted pair infrastructure that had been used for many years was simply not capable of meeting the bandwidth requirements of services like HDTV. Optical fiber with its near limitless bandwidth was an easy choice. Using an active or point-to-point technology, however, would have seen thousands to tens of thousands of strands of optical fiber required from the exchange. Alternately, it would have been necessary to have active equipment in the field from where optical fiber would have been aggregated. Neither of these options was particularly suitable so an alternative technology known as Passive Optical Networks (PON) was developed. PON had the benefit of using small counts of optical fiber from the exchange and then branching out to deliver services to subscribers with passive splitters overcoming the limitations of active Ethernet for this application.

Application and Use 
There is no question that in a “broadacre” environment – one covering large distances - for the delivery of consumer services that PON has many benefits. These benefits though are questionable when it comes to delivering services in other environments such as buildings and other services in commercial buildings or hospitality environments.

Today the benefits of a single converged network to support all applications within a facility are better understood. The simplicity of managing one set of infrastructure, flexibility to add additional services and lower total cost of ownership is now being seen by organizations that head down this path. With 20% of commercial buildings predicted to be smart or intelligent by 2020, this trend will only increase.

The requirements of services that leverage a converged network are quite different to those of the consumer services seen in “broadacre” environments. Services regularly deployed within commercial buildings include telephony, CCTV, signage, wayfinding, wireless, access control, BMS/HVAC and lighting. These applications often require Power over Ethernet (PoE) to power the endpoint, multicast support to manage the distribution of content, symmetric bandwidth to support content moving in both directions, and a high degree of redundancy due to the critical nature of some services. These are inherent within active Ethernet networks but are not typical of passive networks.

Technology aside, another factor to consider is ownership and operation of the network. Passive networks are typically deployed by a carrier or service provider who then takes complete responsibility for the infrastructure and service delivery. When adds, moves or changes are required, this is undertaken by the organization responsible. This is ideal for the delivery of services such as voice, data and telephony to consumers but is less than ideal for building services.

Within commercial buildings there is often a need for the facility owner or manager to reconfigure the network to support new services or add new endpoints. This level of flexibility is simply not available when the network is operated or managed by a carrier or service provider and would generally incur additional costs. This would not occur with an active network that is managed by the facility.

Summary 
So, when it comes to deploying optical fiber to support services, it is not simply a case of an active topology being better than a passive topology or vice versa. Consideration needs to be given to the environment and applications and before a choice is made based on the requirements. In some cases, it may be that both can co-exist – a passive topology to deliver consumer services to residents which would be managed by a carrier and an active topology for building services that would be managed by the facility.

11 Pine Court
Kembrey Park
SN28AD
Swindon, Wiltshire
United Kingdom

Follow:
Twitter   YouTube

See Allied Telesis International BV at IFSEC International 2019

Allied Telesis International BV will be exhibiting on Stand IF1615 at IFSEC International 2019, 18-20 June, ExCeL, London, UK

SCHEDULE MEETING
AlliedWare Plus LAYER 3 FULLY FEATURED SWITCH OPERATING SYSTEM
Product

AlliedWare Plus LAYER 3 FULLY FEATURED SWITCH OPERATING SYSTEM

AlliedWare Plus is the next generation operating system from Allied Telesis, providing advanced IPv4 and IPv6 features, superior robustness, and ease of management.

View product page

IE300 Series - Industrial Managed Switches
Product

IE300 Series - Industrial Managed Switches

Industrial Ethernet Layer 3 Switches Built for enduring performance in harsh environments. This series delivers the performance and reliability demanded by industrial deployments in the Internet of Things (IoT) age.
...

View product page

IE200 Series - Industrial Managed Switches
Product

IE200 Series - Industrial Managed Switches

The Allied Telesis IE200 Series of industrial switches is a cost-effective solution that meets the high reliability requirements demanded by industrial applications. The units can be easily managed through Web GUI, SNMP, Telnet, or SSH while the fiber ports extend the connection distance, increasing t...

View product page

Next-Generation Firewalls
Product

Next-Generation Firewalls

Deep Packet Inspection (DPI) Firewall The Allied Telesis Firewall is a next-generation, Deep Packet Inspection (DPI) engine that provides real-time, Layer 7 classification of network traffic. Rather than being limited to filtering packets based on protocols and ports, the firewall can determine the app...

View product page

x950 Series - High Capacity Stackable Layer 3+ Switches
Product

x950 Series - High Capacity Stackable Layer 3+ Switches

Ideal for high-performing modern enterprise network cores, where stacking creates a resilient local or distributed solution. These powerful switches have 100 Gigabit connectivity built-in, and are expandable, delivering the capacity to enable today’s Smart City and IoT networks. Maximize performance with...

View product page

x230 Series Enterprise PoE+ Gigabit Edge Switches
Product

x230 Series Enterprise PoE+ Gigabit Edge Switches

The Allied Telesis x230 Series of Layer 2+ Gigabit switches offers an impressive set of features in a compact design for flexible deployment. Power over Ethernet capability makes them ideal for connecting and remotely powering access and security devices at the network edge.

View product page

x510 Series Stackable Gigabit Edge Switches
Product

x510 Series Stackable Gigabit Edge Switches

The Allied Telesis x510 Series of advanced stackable Gigabit edge switches offers comprehensive resiliency, security, and management features in a compact, highly-reliable package.

These switches can be easily upgraded from Layer 2+ to a full Layer 3 feature set with a software license pack...

View product page

AMF Cloud
Service

AMF Cloud

AMF Cloud allows your Autonomous Management Framework™ (AMF) Master and/or Controller to be virtual appliances, rather than integrated into an Allied Telesis switch or firewall. This means you get all the functionality of integrated hardware-based management, with the added advantages of private or publi...

View product page

TQ Series Enterprise Class Wireless Access Points - with Channel Blanket Technology
Product

TQ Series Enterprise Class Wireless Access Points - with Channel Blanket Technology

TQ Series Enterprise Class Wireless Access Points Enjoy a high-capacity, reliable wireless network with low operating costs by making your network simple to configure, monitor and manage.

- Ope...

View product page

x530 Series - Gigabit Stackable Layer 3 Switches
Product

x530 Series - Gigabit Stackable Layer 3 Switches

Powerful Gigabit switches with high capacity, resiliency and easy management, making them the ideal choice for demanding distribution and network access applications.

- Build resilient networks with the ability to stack multiple units- Extend network reach with distributed backbones that are easy to ...

View product page

x550 Series - 10 Gigabit Layer 3 Stackable Switches
Product

x550 Series - 10 Gigabit Layer 3 Stackable Switches

The Allied Telesis x550 Series of stackable 10 Gigabit Layer 3 switches feature advanced resiliency and capacity coupled with effortless management, to meet the needs of even the most demanding network core and distribution applications.

- Build a resilient network core or distribution solution with ...

View product page

List your business for free

Create a business listing on the UK's leading security and fire directory

Get the IFSEC Global newsletter

The latest security and fire news, trends and insights

Close
FOR MORE INFORMATION CONTACT ALLIED TELESIS INTERNATIONAL BV
* Oops!
* Oops!
* Oops!
* Oops!
* Oops!
I have read, understood and consent to your Privacy Policy
* sorry this is a required field
MESSAGE SENT!

Thanks for using IFSEC Global Directory,

Your enquiry has been sent to the selected companies, they will be in contact shortly.